Collecting of Antique Ceramics in Singapore

 

In Singapore, interest in collecting of antique ceramics as a hobby likely emerged from around 1930s.   Over a span of around 80 years, the scope and types of  ceramics collected had evolved.  It would be interesting to identify some of the circumstances and major events which shaped and determined the contents of collection of the collectors over this period of time.

 

The Beginning - Ancient trade ceramics from graves and heirlooms in Southeast Asia

A Straits Time article on 12 Jan 1950 featured an antique ceramic collector, Mr Han Wai Toon.  From that interview, we can glean some interesting facts.  The early Singapore collectors of his time collected mainly trade ceramics exported from China to Southeast Asia during Tang to Qing period.  Han Wai Toon (韩槐准)was a Singapore collector of ancient trade Ceramics. His collection was formed in the 1930/50s. Most of his pieces originated from Indonesia and Malaya. In the Straits Times Interview on 12 Jan 1950, he talked about his collecting journey and shared his views on the ancient Chinese ceramic trade to Southeast Asia. He also disclosed that Indonesian dealers from Padang in Sumatra were the traditional suppliers of ancient trade Ceramics to Singapore collectors.

In fact, after a disruption during Konfrontasi (1963-1966), the Indonesian antique pedlers continued to bring in ceramics to Singapore and in the late 60s/70s, the South Asia Hotel in Bencoolen Street was where they congregated to sell their wares.

Han was also a well known pioneering researcher on ancient trade Ceramics and published a book entitled "Ancient Chinese Ceramic Found in Nanyang". He was probably one of the earliest person to explore Johor Lama and wrote about 16th/17th ancient Chinese ceramic fragments recovered from the site. Johor Lama was once the political centre of the Johore Sultanate.

In 1952 he was accepted as a member of the UK Oriental Ceramic Society through the recommendation of the director of then Raffles Museum in Singapore. He donated a large Ceramic collection totaling 276 pieces to the Beijing Palace Museum and moved to China in 1962 and worked as a researcher and consultant in the Palace Museum. He passed away in 1970.

In 2019, there was an exhibition jointly organised by the Hainan and Palace Museum featuring 100 pieces of his donated trade ceramics. Han is a Hainanese and it is not coincidental that Hainan Museum was chosen as the venue for the exhibition in memory of one of its illustrious son. Some of the pieces on display are shown below:

Ming Blue and white ewer with floral decoration

Late Ming Swatow plate with overglaze enamelled decoration

Late Ming Swatow blue and white plate

18th Cent. Qing blue and white plate


Late Qing cup with overglaze enamelled floral decoration for the Peranankan community.  During Han's time, the term Nonya ware was still unknown.  This group of porcelains with decorative elements specifically designed to meet the aesthetic requirement of the peranankan community, was just classified as finer ware for the rich by Han.
 

The Straits Time article of the interview on 12 Jan 1950:

http://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/…/Article/straitstimes19500112…

Straits Time article on 5 Jan 1961:

http://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/…/Ar…/freepress19610105-1.2.114

 

During Han's time, excavated export ceramics , ranging from Tang to Qing period, was the focus of collection.  In comparison to what we know now about the origin and dating of the export ceramics, the knowledge was still in the infancy stage. Collectors would have to be contented with a general dating and the place of production of many of the export ceramics was still unknown. It was only in the last 50 odd years that large amount of archaeological surveys and studies were undertaken by the Chinese and help to clarify the origin and dating of many of the export ceramics.  To know more about the range of trade ceramics that were exported, please read below article: Maritime silk route Trade Ceramics

 

Emergence of ceramics produced in Southeast Asia as respectable collectable items

The Southeast Asian Ceramic Society founded in 1969 made significant contribution in promoting appreciation of ceramic art. It’s inaugural exhibition at the University of Singapore Art Museum in 1971 showcasing ceramic art of Southeast Asia was a milestone event. Its founding President, William Willetts was instrumental in promoting the study and research on trade ceramics made in Thailand, Vietnam and Cambodia. It filled an important gap in our understanding of ancient trade ceramics.  To have an idea of the type of Southeast Asian ceramics that were exported, please read this article: Southeast Asian Ceramics.

 

Chinese Chuang Hui period (创汇期) - Export of domestic type antique Chinese Ceramics

Besides ancient trade ceramics, large quantity of late Qing/Republic Chinese porcelains also made their way to Singapore in the 1950/70s.  After the founding of the People's Republic of China on 1 Oct 1949,  the Chinese government started to produce various forms of handicrafts for export to create revenue.  This period till the 1980s is now general called Chuang Hui period (创汇期).   Enormous quantity of Qing/Republican period ceramics were also targetted as export items.  In Singapore, only a few traditional firms with established Chinese connection were allowed to import porcelains through the annual spring trade fair in Guangzhou. The Singapore firms were there to purchase crockery but were required to take in some old porcelains as part of the transaction.   The Chinese was anxious to clear warehouses brimming over with old porcelains acquired from the common folks.  It turned out to be a mutually satisfactory arrangement.  The old porcelains, mainly dating to late Qing to Republican period, were hugely popular with Singapore antique collectors. The bulk consisting of Jingdezhen wares with decoration in blue and white or overglaze enamelled fencai, wucai or qianjiang and also the various monochrome wares.  There were also some quantity of ceramics made in Fujian and Guangdong.  These were mainly produced for the domestic market and hence widened the choice and range for collectors who in the past have access to mainly trade ceramics

Late Qing Vase imported from China, usually it has the red wax Jian Ding (鉴定) mark
 

Treasure from the sea - Shipwreck ancient trade ceramics

The successful auction of large quantities of Chinese porcelain known as "Nanking cargo"  by Christie's in Amsterdam in 1986 stimulated interest in shipwreck trade ceramics among collectors.  With many in the sea yet to be found, it has now become the main source of trade ceramics as those originating from graves have been exhausted.  For more on shipwreck ceramics, please read this article: Shipwrecks with ceramic cargo found in Southeast Asia.  In 2015, a local collector organised an exhibition of trade ceramics in his shop at Chinatown.  Majority of the pieces originated from shipwrecks and gave a good survey of the types of ancient trade ceramics that were found. Below are some photos from the exhibition.

Tang shipwreck Changsha wares

5 Dynasties/Northern Song shipwreck Yue wares

Song/Yuan Longquan and Jingdezhen wares

Northern Song shipwreck Guangdong ceramics

 

Song/Yuan Fujian shipwreck ceramics

Ming Jingdezhen blue and white wares

Qing Jingdezhen export ware for European market

Song/Qing Fujian white wares 

 

Era of rampant grave/tomb looting and smuggling activities in China

The Chinese Economic Reform initiated in 1978 vastly altered the antique collecting landscape.  There was rampant looting of tombs/graves for burial artefacts to feed the lucrative international antique market.  Over a duration of more than 20 years, countless quantity of burial artefacts, ranging from Neolithic to Qing period, were smuggled out to Macau and Hongkong.  A substantial amount was brought in to Singapore by Fujian peddlers from Macau/Hongkong and ended in many local collections.  As the bulk were ancient ceramics produced for the domestic market, they enriched the depth of collection of local collectors. 

Neolithic jar with iron-black geometric decoration

Han green lead glaze tripod censer

21st Century - Dawn of Internet Age

The internet Age heralded a new era with greater connectivity and explosion of information and misinformation.  Online website such as Ebay and Yahoo enable the Singaporean collectors to have greater access to extant export wares found in Europe and America.  Although we do find some of those in the region, the range that could be found in the West was much more wide ranging and of better quality. 

 

Information on antique ceramics are now widely available online and social media websites such as Facebook have facilitated exchanges of views and opinions.  But for new collectors, it can also be rather trying and confusing. They can be overwhelmed by the deluge of information.  One need to build up the ability to identify useful information and ignore the wrong information sometime offered by the well-intentioned.

 

Nonya Porcelain - A specialised Category of Collection

In the context of Singapore and Malaysia, there is a need to touch on an unique group of 19th/20th cent. porcelain termed Nonya ware.  Interest in it as a specialised field of collection was heightened after the publication of the book "Straits Chinese Porcelain - A Collector's Guide" by Ho Wing Meng in 1983.   Peranakans are widely believed to be descendants of Chinese immigrant traders who married local Malay women or Bataks from Sumatra. Peranakan males are known as babas while the females are known as nonyas.   They were also generally from a higher socio-economic class than most Chinese immigrants.  They retained many of their ethnic and religious practices (such as ancestor worship), but also assimilated the language and culture of the Malays.

An interesting aspect of the Peranakan material culture is the unique group of Chinese porcelains with specific vibrant overglaze colours decoration made in Jingdezhen to cater to the aesthetic taste of the community.  They consisted of mainly utilitarian articles: plates, bowls, teacups, wine-cups, dishes, spoons, teapots, food-containers, basins, spittoons, incense-burners, joss-stick holders, covered pots known as kamchengs and chupus.  The most distinctive decorative design depicts blossoming peonies with phoenixes.  Majority of the pieces are decorated with a border design consisting of 4 or the full 8 elements of the Ba Bao (八宝), i.e. the 8 precious emblems derived from Buddhist art. They are the Endless Knot, Treasure Vase, Lotus Flower, two Golden Fish, Parasol, Conch Shell, Dharma Wheel and Banner of Victory.  The emphasis on the phoenix and peony design does not however preclude the use of other motifs.  Among them, chrysanthemums, lotus and plum blossoms are often found in combination with peonies to form the flowers of four seasons theme. Other commonly found decorative elements include pomegranates, melons, butterflies, pheasants, peacocks and etc.  The background of the vessel is either left in white or filled with green, rose pink, yellow, blue, coral red or brown colour.

Group of Nonya wares in the Singapore Peranakan Museum

Singapore Collectors donations to NUS Museum

Many of the past collections of the Singapore collectors have not survived the passage of time. But it is fortunate that quite a few collectors have made some donations to the museums. In the NUS Museum, there is a room where the pieces are on display, all cluttered together but still quite a feast for the eye.  The main sources of the pieces are likely from grave excavations or heirlooms of natives in Southeast Asia and those from the crazy period of grave lootings from China in the 1980/90s.

Antique ceramics donated by past Singapore collectors

Group of black wares mainly from Fujian, Henan and Jiangxi kilns

Group of Song/Yuan Green wares

Group of Yuan/Ming Cizhou jars

Group of Export Yuan/Qing blue and white ware

Impressive Ming Jiajing blue and white jar

Impressive Ming Interregnum blue and white Jar

Group of Yuan/Qing Fujian white wares

Impressive Ming Fahua Jar

Ming/Qing overglaze enamelled export wares

Ming/Qing Monochrome wares

Qing monochrome and overglaze enamelled wares

15/16th Cent. Thai export wares

15/16th cent. Thai and Vietnamese Ceramics

Concluding Remarks

Since the new millennium, Chinese dealers have been actively sourcing Chinese ceramics from the international antique markets and private collectors.  In Singapore, majority of the quality pieces were acquired by them and the prices have escalated tremendously.   For the new collectors, it is now much more difficult to build up a decent collection.  The journey is fraught with many obstacles and risks, among them the proliferation of good fakes , diminishing supply and high prices.  On the positive side, social media has opened up  a new world where old experienced collectors can share their knowledge with the new collectors and hence can shorten their learning curve.  Collectors are also able to gain access to direct sources of supply and bypass the dealers.

Written by : NK Koh (21 Mar 2020)

  

blog stats